Good Reason

It's okay to be wrong. It's not okay to stay wrong.

Page 67 of 126

Mixing poligion and relitics

You know what I’m going as for Hallowe’en? Myself! I’m a Godless American, and I’m scaaary!

In other news, it seems you can’t be a Christian and vote for Obama. Well, not a true Christian. And she’s got the Bible verses to prove it.

What’s the scariest thing about anti-gay Prop 8?

The scariest thing about Proposition 8 isn’t what passage or failure to pass the measure will do. It is the unrelenting attack on Mormons for having the courage to not just espouse their beliefs and values but to put their money where their principles are.

I can think of lots scarier things than that. Like giving a group of people license from God to unleash their worst and most fearful impulses. No kidding: take a bunch of people and tell them that
a) their society and children are in danger,
b) gays and gay sympathisers are responsible, and
c) their god wants them to defend their values
and you’re playing with a powder keg.

No, the scariest thing about Prop 8 is the effect it has on Mormons. I know Latter-day Saints to be basically decent and sincere people, and their leadership seems intent on turning them into hateful hypocrites. And check this out: when the best among them manage to avoid the transformation, the more orthodox members excoriate them for it. They are causing a division that will be slow in healing.

Religion is child abuse: The movie

What would motivate someone to turn their adorable children into hate-filled bigots? Only one thing I can think of. (Hint: Starts with ‘r’.)

Update: Here’s the link.

On the small chance that that little boy does happen to turn out gay (always a chance), I hope he can get away from his parents fast enough. Otherwise it’s a lifetime of low self-worth. Sad.

Via Glenn Greenwald.

Going rogue

The discomfort between McCain and Palin would appear to have flared into animus.

With 10 days until Election Day, long-brewing tensions between GOP vice presidential candidate Gov. Sarah Palin and key aides to Sen. John McCain have become so intense, they are spilling out in public, sources say.

Several McCain advisers have suggested to CNN that they have become increasingly frustrated with what one aide described as Palin “going rogue.”

A second McCain source says she appears to be looking out for herself more than the McCain campaign.

“She is a diva. She takes no advice from anyone,” said this McCain adviser. “She does not have any relationships of trust with any of us, her family or anyone else.

“Also, she is playing for her own future and sees herself as the next leader of the party. Remember: Divas trust only unto themselves, as they see themselves as the beginning and end of all wisdom.”

I’m noticing something here. McCain can’t be thrilled that he’s tied to Palin. She wasn’t his first choice, but he was ensnared by her magnetism or whatever it was. She doesn’t know anything, says foolish things in public, and when most people hear her speak her mind, they’re horrified. But of course it’s too late for McCain to dump her; would have been too late four weeks ago. And now she won’t shut up. You can’t make her. No one tells Queen Wingnutta what to do! She answers to a higher power, whether it’s her god or her own monstrous ambition.

Now imagine John McCain as the Republican Party, and Sarah Palin as the Christian Right. It’s the exact same relationship. They’re just like she is. They’re for creationism, abstinence, and other things that don’t work. At one point, it must have looked like a good idea to court the votes of the most ignorant and superstitious segment of the population — face it, there’s a lot of them. But once all those Christians became the wingnut base, the Republican party could not easily isolate itself from the consequences. They demanded to be fed, and the GOP obliged: conservative Supreme Court justices, gay marriage, the god-talk. The party became more religiously extremist, to the apparent horror and revulsion of regular people everywhere. It doesn’t matter to the wingnut base. Their loyalty is not with the Republican Party; they answer to a higher power. And they have anointed their queen.

And so here we are, McCain with the monster of his own creation at his throat. The chickens have met the roost. The biggest dumbasses have taken over the slightly-less-dumb asses.

Election prediction thread

Okay, we’re a little more than a week out. Using a few polling websites, my Magic 8 Ball, and a Ouija board, I’ve put together a map of states that are likely to go Obama. Basically I’ve colored anything blue if it’s a safe blue state, or on the edge. I threw in a few surprises (South Dakota, Georgia). I like the look of it.

I think this is the best outcome we’re likely to see. Granted, 399/538 is a real landslide.

So what’s your scenario? Give us a map, or just tell us
– President (duh), electoral votes, and percentage
– Number of Democratic congress-people
– Number of Democratic Senators
– The outcome for any other pieces of legislation current before the populace

No on 8

The interference of the LDS Church in California politics is deeply troubling. No, scratch that. It’s infuriating. It’s hateful. And it’s wrong. If I hadn’t already written my exit letter, I’d be tempted to rejoin the Mormons just so I can resign again in protest over this issue.

What’s the worst thing about the Mormon Church’s support of Prop. 8? Hmm…

  • The idea of parochial Mormons denying marriage to people they don’t even know, and thinking it’s the will of a supernatural being whose will they are uniquely qualified to know.
  • Quotes by sanctimonious old gits like these.

    “What we’re about is the work of the Lord, and He will bless you for your involvement,” apostle M. Russell Ballard said during the hour-long meeting, which was broadcast to church buildings in California, Utah, Hawaii and Idaho.

  • The duplicity of a church that claims to be politically neutral, only speaking out on ‘moral matters’ — and then redefining political issues as ‘moral’ when it pleases them
  • Enshrining bigotry and inequality in the California constitution
  • Millions of dollars in LDS money going to support all of this. From Sully:

    Californians Against Hate released figures Tuesday showing that $17.67 million was contributed by 59,000 Mormon families since August to groups like Yes on 8. Contributions in support of Prop. 8 total $22.88 million.

  • A tax-free religious group getting to act like a PAC. Once again the priest class is vying for political power, just like in the good old Dark Ages.

Well, there’s a lot that’s detestable about this. Mormons should be livid, even if by and large they’re not. For my part, I’m just hoping that this proposition goes down and goes down hard. I want this to be an embarrassment to the leadership of the Mormon Church. I want them to wonder why their Special Pal in the Sky didn’t come through. I want Mormons to see more and more pictures of happy gay couples at weddings with the rice and the bubbles and the cake, and after they’re through freaking out about living in the End of Days, I want them to notice how happy the newlyweds look, and I hope time will help them reconsider.

I don’t have much to spare these days, but I’m donating to No on 8 because I think this is a huge deal. I’m used to religions making lots of empty doctrinal pronouncements, but when they use their baseless theology against other people, I say it’s gone far enough.

Californians: please vote against this. Even if the news anchors call all the eastern states for Obama early, don’t let that stop you from getting to the polls.

Political LOL

ThinkProgress notes John McCain’s claim that he’s never changed his mind.

MCCAIN: You’ll have to tell me what’s changed. I love it when they say, “Oh McCain has changed.” And I say, “What have I changed on?” They can’t name a single issue or they’ll name an issue and its false. I’m the same guy. I’m proud of our campaign.

In fact, ThinkProgress has listed 44 issues that McCain has flip-flopped on, from torture to taxes to energy.

I don’t mind if someone learns more and changes their views on something. McCain should be doing that every day. But to do this many 180’s and then claim you haven’t is delusional.

Add Palin into the equation, and what do you get?

Sarah Palin sings!

I had no idea she was such a gifted jazz improvisationalist.

The memes of Real Virginia

Sorry I’ve been away. I’ve been thesis-ing, and when you get into a writing spate, you look around and say, “Oh, it’s Wednesday now.”

I confess I’ve also been following the US election obsessively. There’s just too much to say about it. I have sent back my absentee ballot (registered in Washington), marked for Obama and any other downticket D’s I could find.

It’s been so interesting to watch the slow movement across the Democratic parts of the map. The blue started at Minnesota and Michigan, and since then it’s spread to states I didn’t expect. North Dakota’s in play? North Carolina? Virginia! Did you expect Virginia to go for Obama? Even ‘real Virginia‘.

My favourite political ad this year is this radio ad, that aired in Virginia, where bluegrass legend Ralph Stanley describes Obama as a ‘good man’. I really enjoy Stanley’s phonology — the [t] in ‘the’, the elided [l] in ‘help’, the dropped participial ‘g’, the slower, more deliberate cadence — but what really stands out here is the memes he hits. You can infer a lot about a community by their memes:

  • Nobody’s lookin’ for a handout. They value independence and take pride in standing on their on two feet.
  • Barack’ll cut taxes for everyday folks. The Plainfolks strategy runs right through this ad.
  • Our kids shouldn’t have to leave our communities to find work. The brain drain must be ripping these communities apart.
  • He values personal responsibility and ‘family first’. A dog whistle for Republicans. Not sure I like to see it co-opted by Democrats, but perhaps subverting the meme is the first step to dismantling it.
  • Describing Obama as a ‘true friend of the people’. This really sounds old-style populist. Doesn’t it sound like it should be said from off the back of a train, maybe 100 years ago?

This article from the LA Times was interesting too. (I know it’s old.) It sounds like a lot of folks would like to vote for Obama, but it’s making them confront their inner racist. The article concerns the strategies that Obama supporters are using to convince their friends and neighbours.

When Cecil E. Roberts, president of the coal miners union that shapes politics in much of this mountain region, talks to voters, he tells them that their choice is to have “a black friend in the White House or a white enemy.” When Charlie Cox, an Obama supporter, hears friends fretting about Obama’s race, he reminds them that they pull for the nearby University of Tennessee football team, “and they’re black.”

Union organizer Jerry Stallard asks fellow coal workers what’s more important: improving their work conditions or holding onto their skepticism of Obama’s race, culture or religion. “We’re all black in the mines,” he tells them.

If I had to summarise these memes into one, it might be: Reducing the distance between black and white. You’re closer to black folks than you realise, so it’s okay to vote for one.

If the map is any indication, this is working. Pollster.com has Obama up by eight, and I hope it holds. I’m really encouraged to see the nation sort itself out on this issue. I think this means good things.

At dinner tonight









Fear of vanishing

I’ve been viewing the YouTube videos from the Exmormon Foundation. Worth a look. There are some clips from a film called “Line Upon Line”, featuring (mostly) non-angry, pleasant former saints telling their deconversion stories.

One of the stories in Part 2 tapped into something unexpected for me. A young woman says:

Leaving the Church is hard because you are so afraid of what’s going to happen to you. And you don’t have any examples of that because people leave the Church and they scurry away, you know? Like, you don’t know — When you’re in the Church, you do not know any ex-Mormons. You don’t know ’em! And so I was really afraid of leaving the Church because I was like, no way, this can’t be real. What will I do with my life if I leave the Church? Who am I going to be, right? And so, I think that that fear keeps a lot of people, either consciously or subconsciously, in the Church.

Well, that’s about right. In testimony meetings, Latter-day Saints seem to tell each other constantly how they don’t know where they’d be without the Church. They’d probably all be dead. Or in jail. Like everyone else who isn’t in the Church. And Latter-day Saints are routinely warned that if they don’t keep the promises they make in LDS temples, they’ll be in Satan’s power. Have to keep ’em scared of ghosts, you see.

But this quote touched on another part of the scariness that I think I must have harboured without realising. I have known a few people that stopped coming to church. They deleted themselves from the sample, you could say. And, what do you know, they did disappear, and I never saw them again. So the unspoken impression I think I got was: If you leave the Church, you will disappear. How frightening!

It’s nobody’s fault. Just an artifact of participation (or lack thereof) in social groups. But for me it seems a powerful cognitive illusion that I hadn’t noticed before.

So it’s a good thing that I show up every once in a while at church. I drop the boys off to be with their Mom, wearing nice but non-churchy clothes. No, I haven’t disappeared, I tell my old friends. I’m still here, and I’m very happy without religion.

« Older posts Newer posts »

© 2026 Good Reason

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑