Good Reason

It's okay to be wrong. It's not okay to stay wrong.

Brain and accent

Here’s the story: Boy has brain surgery, and comes out with a posh London accent instead of his unlistenable Northern accent.

“We noticed that he had started to elongate his vowels in words like ‘bath’ which he never did before,” said Mrs McCartney-Moore, 45, a music teacher from York.

“He no longer has short vowel sounds – they are all long. It’s bizarre.”

This is reminding me of Foreign Accent Syndrome, where someone will have (say) a stroke and come out with a new accent. Here’s the current explanation for FAS:

Now researchers at Oxford University have found that patients with “foreign accent syndrome” seem to share certain characteristics which might explain the problem.

A small number of them all had tiny areas of damage in various parts of the brain.

This might explain the combination of subtle changes to vocal features such as lengthening of syllables, altered pitch or mispronounced sounds which make a patient’s pronunciation sound similar to a foreign accent.

But for this case, the surgeon has a slightly different idea: the patient had to relearn his accent after the operation, and did so according to the people around him.

Brain surgeon Paul Eldridge, who works at the specialist Walton Neurological Centre, Liverpool, said it was possible that the infection and abscess had affected the area of the brain which controls language skills, forcing William to learn how to speak again.

“It’s as if he’s re-learnt how to talk from listening to language from sources different to those that prompted his speech first time around.”

The key here is: is he really speaking with an upper-class accent (which could have been learned from someone else), or is it just the elongated vowels that makes people think he’s talking with an upper-class accent? How long does it take to acquire an accent, anyway?

1 Comment

  1. How could he have relearned his accent, by that I mean whom did he learn it from? Surely his prior accent was a result of his family environment, and later schooling.

    It MUST be that he is just elongating vowels! so he’s not really speaking with an accent… but he is… Hmm, might have to change the definition of accent in my head. He has an accent but its not an ‘accent’ haha. mm.

    It could actually be a problem as a result of the surgery, if he was speaking normally just after the procedure and for a couple of days there might be some other biological reason.

    And apparently it only takes a few weeks to learn an accent! well, in his case…

    I find it interesting that he can play the piano and trumpet better now than before! awesome.

    But anyway, just throwing some ideas up in the air.

Comments are closed.

© 2024 Good Reason

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑